At the market booth, people ask us some version of this every week: “I already take ashwagandha capsules. Is a tincture any different?” We make tinctures, so we are biased. Here is the honest version anyway, including the places where capsules are the better choice.
What is actually in each one
Most ashwagandha capsules hold one of two things: dried root ground to a powder, or a concentrated extract, often standardized to a stated percentage of withanolides. Some also include leaf. The label should tell you which.
A tincture is the plant soaked in alcohol and water for a long time, then pressed. Ours starts with fresh root, grown on our farm and partner farms in the Pacific Northwest, at a fresh root-to-liquid ratio of 1:2. The only other ingredients are organic cane alcohol (40% or less) and filtered water. It is also a spagyric, which means the minerals from the spent root go back into the bottle. Here is what that word means.
At a glance
| Capsules | Our tincture | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Dried powder or a concentrated extract | Fresh root in organic cane alcohol and water |
| Taste | None | Earthy and strong |
| Alcohol | None | Yes, 40% or less |
| Serving | Fixed per capsule | 1 mL, easy to make smaller |
| Travel | Easy | A glass bottle |
Fresh root versus dried powder
This is what we hear more than anything else. People who have worked with dried ashwagandha powder for years, in capsules or by the spoonful, try the fresh tincture and tell us it is not the same thing. They say it plainly, and they say it often.
We believe it is a real difference, and we believe the reason is the fresh root. Drying changes a plant, the way it changes any fresh food. Ours never goes through it: the roots are in the jar within days of coming out of the ground.
We are farmers, not a lab, so we cannot hand you a study that settles it. What we can give you is years of people telling us the same thing across the market table, and coming back. We wrote more about why fresh is different.
Where capsules win
No taste. Ashwagandha tastes like what it is, a root. Some people love that. Plenty do not.
No alcohol. Our tincture contains organic cane alcohol, and adding it to a hot drink does not make it alcohol-free. If you avoid alcohol, a tincture like ours may not meet your needs.
Closest to the research. Much of the published research on ashwagandha has used standardized root extracts taken as capsules. If matching what was studied matters most to you, that is the form to look for.
Easy to carry. A bottle of capsules goes in a bag without a second thought.
Where a tincture wins
Fresh, not dried. For us this is the big one, as above.
You choose the amount. A serving of ours is 1 mL, about 30 drops, once or twice a day. With a dropper it is simple to begin with less and see how it sits with you. Do not go above the serving on the label without guidance from a qualified healthcare professional.
Nothing to swallow. Take it straight or in a little water. For people who struggle with pills, that alone settles it.
A short ingredient list. Root, alcohol, water. No capsule shell, fillers or flow agents.
What to check on any label
- Which part of the plant: root, leaf, or both.
- Fresh or dried.
- How much is in a serving, and how concentrated it is.
- Every other ingredient.
- Where it was grown, if the label says.
The short answer
Choose capsules if you avoid alcohol, dislike strong flavors, or want a fixed, standardized amount. Choose a tincture if you want fresh root instead of dried powder, want to adjust your serving, or prefer not to swallow pills.
If the tincture is your answer, our Fresh Ashwagandha is here, and this is how to take it.
Do not use ashwagandha during pregnancy or while breastfeeding. Talk with a qualified healthcare professional before use if you take medication or have a medical condition. More in our FAQ.
With Warm Ashwagandha Wishes,
Jeff and the Portland Ashwagandha Farm Team
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
0 comments